The Imperial Star Destroyer could send out TIE Fighters, plus they rarely travel alone. I doubt the Enterprise could take down multiple Destroyers as well as their collective fighters. Not to mention the possibility of Vader being on the ship. Captain Kirk has no defense against the Dark Side. Or better acting.
I read through those links and it actually says the Star Wars shields would be better. There's a couple problems with their 'research' though (one being its a Star Wars based site so there's bound to be a confirmation bias). They rule out the Star Trek Technical Manual as canon, why just because that's why... it was written by the writers of the show based on the episodes up to that time how can it not be cannon. Then when looking at the Star Wars shields they dismiss anything that points to the shields being crappy as being non canon (even if its in the ORIGINAL movies) and quote from the 100's of novels written by joe shmoe as if they're canon... I could spend the next hour going back and forth through the holes in most of his arguments but the fact I've looked at it this long is making me a bit sad lol.
It's your #0 visit here. It's about time to stop lurking!
Sharenator.com is all about sharing, voting, competing and simply having fun. Who's the best at posting the coolest stuff? Join now and benefit from all of sharenator's features available only to members. Be the Sharenator!
Just googled it. Sad that someone did all the research for me on this.
http://www.stardestroyer.net/Empire/Tech/Shields/Shield1.html
/> http://www.stardestroyer.net/Empire/Tech/Shields/Shield2.html